Ashes of Al'ar always been #1 for me before I got it & even more so when I got lucky! Only raided Karazhan & Gruul's Lair during Burning Crusade live content. Only ever saw one person with it back then & loved it. Was so happy when my time of soloing Tempest keep finally paid off. Really love the Headless Horseman's mount too. Still never any luck in Stratholme though :(
Oh i see what you did there!
Because the damned thing is impossible to find?